A few days before the school holidays, we received the student report for our older son. I talked to my wife privately, saying, "I think he has done well as a junior primary schooler. In fact, I don't want him to be too excellent at the beginning, as I am afraid he might be upset if he cannot always maintain that level of excellence. I'm fine as long as he can catch up with others." While I was talking about this, I could not help but recall my own experiences as a student in the past.
I was always a poorly performing student during the early years of my primary school. One day, the teacher required me and a few other students to stay in the classroom because she wanted to chat with our parents when they picked us up. When the parents arrived, she told them we were students falling behind others. Some parents blamed their children immediately upon hearing this, while my mother responded gently to the teacher, "I don't know how to teach him, so I hope the teachers from the school can support him more if needed."
The next day, the teacher praised the parents who had blamed their kids and criticised my mum, saying that she was not a responsible parent. My poor performance continued until Grade Five, when my dad started to guide me. He checked my homework every day. One day, he told me I was wrong on a question in the homework. The question stated that there was a metal sheet with a given width and length forming a rectangle, and if we wanted to cut small circles with a given radius, how many of them could be cut? In the answer I provided, I calculated the area of the rectangle, then calculated the area of the circle, and divided the former by the latter to get the result.
Dad drew a picture in a sketch book and said, "Cutting circles is different from cutting squares from a metal sheet, as there must be some corner materials that cannot be used." He asked me to use a ruler to draw the rectangle and label square grids whose side length was the same as the circle's diameter, and directly count the number from there.
The next day, the teacher said what I did was wrong and that the standard answer was the same as my previous solution. "My dad said this was impractical." I said to the teacher and explained like dad. "I think what your dad said is partially correct, as in practical applications, it should be like what he said." the teacher replied, "But in the exam, you still have to do it the same way as the standard answer, as the motivation of the question is to examine whether you know how to calculate the area of a circle from the radius. In your approach, you can't tell others that you can master this."
Under dad's guidance for my studies, I made rapid progress and, in Grade Six, I became one of the top students. After studying at a junior high school near home for three years, I was offered a position at our city's most prestigious senior high school. Moreover, I was selected for the so-called "Top Students' Class"—a class that was formed by the top 50 students in the grade. Within this competitive environment, I was no longer a top student anymore, which meant I also lost attention from the teachers. I became a low-performing student after staying in the class for a year. Then it was time for students to choose whether they liked to study STEM or the humanities and social sciences. Most students in my class chose physics, and so did I. Our class then became the class formed by the top students who selected physics. A few students in physics had fallen behind others in my class a little bit, so they were kicked out of my class and transferred to an ordinary class. Their academic performance suddenly boosted after that, while I finally became the last one in my class that year.
In the final year of senior high school, my academic performance was always within the range of the bottom ten students, and I had significantly fallen behind a few students from other classes.
"He has actually done quite a lot of exercises in his homework," the physics teacher said. "However, he always gets poor marks in the exams." Then suddenly all the students laughed, staring at me with prejudiced faces.
I became too stressed when the Gaokao, the entrance examination for universities, was approaching. In the mock exams, I was so anxious that I couldn't help but suffer from diarrhea during the exams, and I didn't have enough time to finish answering the questions.
Based on the results of the mock examinations, our school arranged for the top 50 students to have additional lessons. Most of them were from my classroom, while only one to two students were from others. I was not included within that group. Every afternoon, about ten or so students who were considered "losers" from my classroom studied by ourselves, while most of my classmates went to another room to receive extra instruction. No teachers came to our classroom to supervise us. No one even cared whether we were really studying. Students from other classes were treated very differently. As only a few of them had the opportunity to attend the extra lessons, the teachers would sit in their classrooms to supervise the remaining students. Every time I went to the teachers' office, my teachers would be surrounded by those top students, so I didn't get an opportunity to ask questions and seek help. I had been given up on by my school.
The reason I was given up on was that I had fallen behind in a class formed by top students at the beginning of senior high school. I regretted studying so hard during my years of junior high school. I knew I would at least receive more support if I hadn't been selected for this special class—a class that was designed to help top students achieve the highest marks in exams so they could go to the top two universities in China.
"Which questions do you want me to talk about?" When our teachers asked such questions in the classroom, I shouted out the numbers of the questions that I didn't understand. I shouted so loudly that my voice muted everyone else's. The teacher was embarrassed, while a few students frowned as if saying, "We already know how to do these simple questions," or, "It's a waste of our time." I didn't feel guilty at all despite this, as I knew the school's arrangements were very unfair to me. The teachers had to talk a bit about the questions I raised.
One day, the head teacher of my classroom began to ask poorly performing students to her office one by one, and she said she wanted to offer some support and express concern for those who had been ignored for a long time. I was one of them. She asked me why I was so stressed and whether I needed other support. I then said I would try my best to manage the stress. After she met with all of those students, she suddenly came back to the classroom and blamed me in front of the whole class, criticising my gestures for not being elegant and my words for not being mature enough. I was shocked. I thought even if my gestures were not elegant or my language was not mature, she should not be offended like that. I didn't know why she was suddenly angry with me and spent more than half an hour blaming me in the classroom, in front of all my classmates, just some weeks before the examinations. If she really wanted to educate me, why not tell me in a private conversation after the examinations? I didn't think the matters were that urgent. Instead, I felt I was innocent. Many years later, when I thought back to this incident, I realised the teacher was lying in front of all the students. She didn't care about my behaviour or words; rather, she minded me shouting out during lessons to request that the teachers explain what I didn't understand. There must have been other students who thought I wasted their time. But I still didn't believe it was my fault.
After all, even if I was given up on by the school and teachers, they should not have treated me like that. As a student in the school, I should have received equal support compared to those top-performing ones. Especially since my academic records were far above the average in my grade. I was only falling behind in my class because it was a special one filled with students selected from exams at the beginning. I knew I most likely wouldn't have opportunities to get into top universities in cities with a high standard of living, so I focused on universities located in Northwestern or Northeastern China, as they were not as competitive as the province I was living in.
I was finally accepted by a top institution for electronic science in Xi'an and studied telecommunications engineering. In the first semester, my academic performance was far below the average. However, I caught up with the average in the second semester. From the second year onward, I continued to improve and became a top student in my class. Many years later, when I recalled this, I thought of a doctor's judgment during a physical checkup after I recovered from mumps as a teenager. He said some aspects of my puberty development progressed slower than average. Despite this still being normal, it might have triggered a brain development delay for a few years, which was a disadvantage during the university entrance exams.
In the final semester of the final year, all students needed to do a final project. At first, I wanted to devote all my energy to it, but my supervisor told me to use a few network simulation software platforms, such as OPNET and NS2. Later, as I planned to study in Australia, I spent a lot of time preparing for the IELTS exam. Once I finished the examination, I had less than a month left for the final project. I didn't have time to learn those network simulation tools. I spent some time reading a research paper instead and used the C programming language to write a simulation program for an algorithm from that paper, which shocked my supervisor. But later he said that due to our university's policy, students who wanted to be accepted into a postgraduate course with entrance exam exemptions had to achieve straight A's in their grades, while those who would study a postgraduate course at our university had to get a B. For others, the best possible grade allowed was a C. Since I had a plan to study abroad, he argued with the review panel and finally managed to give me a B. How ridiculous!
In 2017, just a few days before I went to Shenzhen for a job interview, I received a meeting invitation from QUT to discuss plagiarism within a PhD thesis written by a QUT graduate who was working at CMU as an associate professor. During the meeting, the staff from QUT said the thesis contained statements copied from others. They asked me how I wanted them to deal with the issue. I said they should do what they had to do according to QUT's rules. A couple of months later, I received an email from the head of school at QUT. He said they had contacted the professor from CMU and he had corrected those parts containing plagiarism. QUT would replace the old thesis with the new one online so that in the future, people would not find the same problems in the thesis.
I then understood why plagiarism was so popular in the academic world.